The Speaker presides over the meetings of the House and rules on points of procedure. It is a role of great significance in a parliamentary democracy and it has a colourful past.
Historical context
The Speaker’s role has evolved over centuries of British parliamentary history. Its origin in 14th-century England is expressed in the title ‘Speaker’ being one who speaks for the House and represents the House to the Crown (King or Queen). While early Speakers were often viewed as agents of the Crown, the role became pivotal in times of struggle between the Crown and the House of Commons, captured in essence in 1642 when Charles I entered the House of Commons to arrest five members for treason. The Speaker refused to give the members’ whereabouts, saying ‘I have neither eyes to see, nor tongue to speak in this place, but as the House is pleased to direct me.’
It is a common myth that Speakers have been executed in the course of carrying out their duties. While it is true that between 1399 and 1535 nine people who had once held the office of Speaker were executed or suffered violent deaths, those demises can be attributed to causes (such as armed conflict) other than carrying out the function of Speaker. Their premature ends must be viewed in the context of the times, especially the period of the Wars of the Roses. However, the responsibilities still weighed heavily in uncertain times when free speech could not be taken for granted.
Current New Zealand context
New Zealand’s Speaker still has a formal role in representing the House to the Sovereign, such as presenting the Address in Reply,
but the main visible function is to chair the meetings of the House and to rule on procedure. To illustrate the importance of the role, the Speaker is numbered third in New Zealand’s official order of precedence after the Governor-General and the Prime Minister.
The Speaker is elected from among members at the first meeting of the House after a general election. There was a longstanding tradition of showing some resistance to taking up this position, perhaps due to the execution myth (see above), but this no longer occurs in New Zealand. Candidates must nominate themselves. To be confirmed in office and to lay claim to the privileges of the House, the Speaker-elect then calls on the Governor-General. The Speaker remains in office for the term of the Parliament.
The Speaker maintains some links with his or her political party, unlike the United Kingdom where all links are severed after becoming Speaker. The Speaker is, however, expected to act impartially and does not participate in debate in the House, but can participate in debate in committee of the whole House.
The Speaker has an ordinary vote in the House but no casting vote. The Speaker’s vote is included in the collective vote of the party he or she was elected to represent. This ensures party proportionality determined at the general election is maintained. If a personal vote is held (for conscience issues, for instance), the Speaker votes individually, like any other member.
In addition to presiding over the House, the Standing Orders (procedural rules) of the House confer upon the Speaker a number of functions to be carried out on behalf of the House. These include issuing a summons for a witness to appear before a committee or for the production of documents and considering matters of privilege raised by members.
The Speaker has some statutory functions (specific functions established in law) such as those in relation to the Electoral Act 1993. These include the official declaration of a vacancy in the membership of the House of Representatives.
The Speaker chairs three select committees. Two of these, the Business Committee and the Standing Orders Committee, deal with procedural matters. The third, the Officers of Parliament Committee, recommends the annual appropriations (supply of funds) for the Ombudsmen, the Auditor-General, and the Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment.
The Speaker also has functions in relation to parliamentary administration and the parliamentary precincts. There are five public organisations known as either ‘non-public service departments’ or ‘Offices of Parliament’, because their responsibilities are direct to Parliament rather than to Ministers.
The Speaker is accountable to the House for those offices and also chairs the Parliamentary Service Commission, which oversees the Parliamentary Service (a non-public service department that provides support to members and manages the parliamentary complex). For the purposes of the Trespass Act 1980, the Speaker is the legal occupier of the parliamentary precincts.